More Disinformation About Law Faculty Hiring

Over at MoneyLaw Tom Bell is asserting that “at least in terms of hiring, women and minorities enjoy significant advantages.” He bases this claim on data that says nothing about the qualifications of the underlying pool of applicants, and completely ignores data showing a troubling trend in which women are disproportionately hired into nontenure track jobs. He also focuses on “success rates” rather than giving absolute numbers, which tell a very different story. Previous posts at this blog on this subject, with links to various AALS data tables, can be found here, and here. See also this.

–Ann Bartow

UPDATE: See also Christopher Bracey’s post about this at Blackprof.

Share
Posted in Academia, Feminists in Academia, Law Schools, Law Teaching | Comments Off on More Disinformation About Law Faculty Hiring

Are Sales Falling Because The Commercials Are Lousy, Or Because Miller Lite Beer Is Lousy?

I say both! In any event, as was discussed here last May, the Miller Brewing Co. had been running really awful “Man Laws” advertisements, which Amanda Marcotte at Pandagon gleefully notes have been terminated. Not clear whether it was the sexism of the marketing or the rubbing alcohol aftertaste of the actual beverage that is causing declining sales, but it will be nice not to have to watch those commercials any more.

–Ann Bartow

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture, Sexism in the Media | Comments Off on Are Sales Falling Because The Commercials Are Lousy, Or Because Miller Lite Beer Is Lousy?

Alcohol, Testosterone and Violence

Three members of the football team at Guilford College, a Quaker institution in Greensboro, North Carolina, have been charged with assault and ethnic intimidation of three Palestinian students.   National Public Radio interviewed Guilford’s Dean for Campus Life, Aaron Fetrow.   When asked how the alleged violence could have happened at a school with a pacifist tradition, Mr. Fetrow replied, “There was some alcohol involved.   There was some testosterone involved.   Fights like this happen at campuses all over the country all the time.”  

-Posted by Bridget Crawford

Share
Posted in Acts of Violence | Comments Off on Alcohol, Testosterone and Violence

Arse Poetica Is Correct…

She has posted one of the best photographs ever taken. When you get to her blog, click on it to bring up a larger version.

–Ann Bartow

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture, Feminist Blogs Of Interest | Comments Off on Arse Poetica Is Correct…

Micro Something, Probably

microad.jpg

Blech. Via Feministing.

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture, Sexism in the Media | Comments Off on Micro Something, Probably

Feminist Law Prof Caitlin Borgmann Presents: The Reproductive Rights Prof Blog!

Check it out here!

borgmann.jpg

She was the State Strategies Coordinator for the ACLU Reproductive Freedom Project from 1997-2002, and really knows her stuff.

Share
Posted in Feminist Blogs Of Interest, Reproductive Rights | Comments Off on Feminist Law Prof Caitlin Borgmann Presents: The Reproductive Rights Prof Blog!

Del Corazon

Sun_mad.jpg

Latino Voices in American Art.

(Above rendering by Ester Hernandez.)

Share
Posted in Bloggenpheffer, Sisters In Other Nations | Comments Off on Del Corazon

The Copyrighted Anne Frank

annefrank.jpg

Like so many people, I read The Diary Of A Young Girl as a child and was powerfully moved by it. The edition I obtained, published in the 1950s and loaned to me by my grandmother, had an Afterward that noted that some portions of the work “of no interest to the reader” had been excised. I spent a lot of time wondering how anyone could possibly think that Anne Frank had written anything in her diary that wasn’t of interest to readers like me. A 1995 “complete” edition revealed that Otto Frank had edited out passages in which Anne detailed her romantic relationship with Peter, and also negative comments she made about her mother. As owner via inheritance of the copyright in the diary, he certainly had the legal right to do this, but I’ve always thought it was a shame that once he made the decision to publish her diary, he felt he needed to manipulate and distort the way she presented herself through her writings.

As I noted in this article, when ABC decided to develop a miniseries on the life of Anne Frank in 2001, the company was unable to obtain the rights to her diary and received litigation threats that caused ABC to direct the project’s creative team to draft a script that did not use a single word of Anne Frank’s writing. Lines were changed to avoid even coincidental similarity to words from her diary, and a writer was kept on the set during the entire shoot to police last-minute script changes. Even then, the Anne Frank-Fonds, a foundation that holds the copyrights in the diary, denounced perceived”substantial similarity between the two works”and threatened legal action. The miniseries had to be constructed so that it avoided not only the copyrighted words of the diary, but also all of the copyrighted expressions contained in previous books, films, television movies, plays and documentaries about Anne Frank.

Now it seems that part of Otto Frank’s story has also remained untold. He died in 1980, but letters he wrote in 1941 have not yet been released, although hopefully that will happen soon. From Yahoo News:

Desperate letters written by the father of Anne Frank, the teenager whose diary of hiding from Nazis documented the horror of Jews during World War II, have surfaced in the United States and will be released next month.

Otto Frank wrote the letters in 1941 in a despairing effort to get his family out of Nazi-occupied Amsterdam, before finally hiding the family, including Anne, in secret rooms in an Amsterdam office building for two years until they were betrayed, Time magazine said Thursday.

The family was sent to Nazi prison camps where Anne, her sister Margot, and their mother Edith died before the war’s end. But Otto Frank survived and returned to Amsterdam where he recovered his daughter’s diary of their time hiding from the Nazis.

He had it published and eventually, under the title “Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl,” it turned into a best-seller in the United States and other countries.

In 1959 a movie was made from the book, “The Diary of Anne Frank.”

The sheaf of Otto Frank’s letters, about 80 documents in total, show him seeking escape routes to Spain, exit visas from Paris and help to get to the United States or Cuba, all in vain.

They were discovered by a researcher at the YIVO Institute for Jewish Research two years ago. But concerns over copyright and other legal issues compelled YIVO to keep their existence quiet until now, Time said. The New York Institute will release the letters on February 14, it said.

Like Anne’s diary, Otto Frank’s letters sound like they will offer powerful testimony about the tragedy and human cost of the Holocaust. Copyright laws aren’t what motivated Otto Frank to write them, and seem to have failed miserably at incentivizing their distribution so far.

–Ann Bartow

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture | Comments Off on The Copyrighted Anne Frank

What was Bush Wearing? What Was Cheney Wearing? What was Autrey Wearing? What Was Webb Wearing?

Who knows? The only outfits mentioned in this NYT article about last night’s SOTU are Nancy Pelosi’s:

Appearances were obviously important to Ms. Pelosi, who changed from the brown suit she had worn earlier in the day to a soft green one, which offered more contrast to her dark leather speaker’s chair.

And Autrey’s daughters’:

The chamber erupted most unanimously and loudly for Wesley Autrey, the man who leapt into the tracks of a New York subway to save a fellow passenger. (The only ones not clapping, it appeared, were Mr. Autrey’s two young daughters, who napped beside him in their bubblegum-colored dresses.)

–Ann Bartow

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture, Sexism in the Media | Comments Off on What was Bush Wearing? What Was Cheney Wearing? What was Autrey Wearing? What Was Webb Wearing?

UK Judges Try to Block Rape Trial Reforms

The British newspaper The Guardian reports:

Government plans for changes in the law to boost rape conviction rates are in disarray after the judges who would have to put them into practice told ministers they oppose them.

The Council of Circuit Judges, the influential body representing all 637 circuit judges in England and Wales, has dismissed all the proposals, including a measure to try to make it easier to convict in cases where the victim was binge-drinking.

The plans are the latest attempt to reverse a plummeting conviction rate for rape that has dropped from 33% of reported cases in 1977 to just 5.29% in 2004. But the judges have rejected all the principal proposals, which include:

· A new statutory definition of capacity to consent to sexual intercourse, which would clarify when a woman can be considered too drunk to make the decision.

· The use of expert witnesses in court to help dispel “rape myths” and inform the jury how rape victims are likely to act. Although this routinely happens in the US, judges here believe their use would cause delays and prove expensive, unnecessary and “inappropriate”.

· Showing videotaped interviews with victims filmed when they first go to the police. Ministers said this would bring home to jurors the victims’ distress. But the judges are concerned that this would be too emotive and not help establish the truth of the allegations. They argue that some people are particularly good at faking distress.

The full story appears here.

–Stephanie Farrior

Share
Posted in Acts of Violence, Legal Profession, Sisters In Other Nations | Comments Off on UK Judges Try to Block Rape Trial Reforms

The Selected Papers of Margaret Sanger

sanger.gif

Volume I: The Woman Rebel, 1900-1928

The birth control crusader, feminist, and reformer Margaret Sanger was one of the most controversial and compelling figures inthe twentieth century. This first volume of The Selected Papers of Margaret Sanger documents the critical phases and influences of an American feminist icon and offers rare glimpses into her working-class childhood, burgeoning feminism, spiritual and scientific interests, sexual explorations, and diverse roles as wife, mother, nurse, journalist, radical socialist, and activist. These letters and other writings, including diaries, journals, articles, and speeches, most of which have never before been published, have been selected and assembled with an eye to telling the story of a remarkable life, punctuated by arrests and imprisonments, exile, love affairs, and a momentous personal loss–a life consumed with the quest for women’s sexual liberation. Because its narrative line is so absorbing, Volume 1 may be read as a powerful biography. Volume 1 covers a twenty-eight-year period from her nurse’s training and early socialist involvement in pre-World War I bohemian Greenwich Village to her adoption of birth control (a term she helped coin in 1914) as a fundamental tenet of women’s rights. It traces the intersection of her life and work with other reformers, activists and leaders of modernity on both sides of the Atlantic, including Havelock Ellis, H. G. Wells, George Bernard Shaw, Emma Goldman, Max Eastman, and Eugene Debs, as well as many leading radical artists and writers of the day. It highlights her legislative and organizational efforts, her support of the eugenics movement, and the alliances she secured with medical professionals in her crusade to make birth control legal, respectable, and accessible. This volume also includes letters from women desperately in need of fertility control who saw Sanger as their last hope. Supplemented by an introduction, brief essays providing narrative and chronological links, and substantial notes, the volume is an invaluable tool for understanding Sanger’s actions and accomplishments.

sanger2.jpg

Volume II: Birth Control Comes of Age (1928-1939)

Volume II documents a difficult period for Sanger as she faced sustained political opposition to getting birth control legislation passed. Documents will track the unsuccessful efforts of her Congressional lobbying group, the National Committee for Federal Legislation on Birth Control, as their repeated efforts to amend the Comstock Act, as well as failed efforts to incorporate birth control into New Deal public health programs. It also will trace efforts to expand the reach of birth control clinics to rural and African-American women as well as Sanger’s decision to shift from legislative to judicial reform. The success of the 1936 U.S. v. One Package decision overturned a major portion of the Comstock Law, resulting in Sanger’s reluctant decision to reunite her Birth Control Clinical Research Bureau with the ABCL in 1939 to form the Birth Control Federation of America, an organization managed by public relations professionals, which in 1942 became the Planned Parenthood Federation of America. The volume will close with the growing threat of war in Europe and Sanger’s efforts to assist the flight of German sex reformers and physicians.

Final editing on Volume II is underway with publication planned in February 2007 by the University of Illinois Press.

Two additional volumes are planned as well.

Share
Posted in Feminism and Law, Feminist Legal History, Recommended Books, Reproductive Rights, Women's Health | Comments Off on The Selected Papers of Margaret Sanger

Ex-armory turns into porn site; SF Chron reporter delighted

Note the strikingly pro-porn slant of this SF Chron article:

Kink, a Web-based pornography distributor, buys historic S.F. building to film its bondage movies

A friendly band of San Francisco pornographers can’t wait to get inside the old armory on Mission Street and start tying people up, artistically.

Not only tying them up, but also spanking them, swatting them, cuffing them and whipping them, with sensitivity.

“This is going to be very exciting,” said porn director James Mogul. “What an opportunity.”

The other day, Mogul paid a visit to the cavernous old armory, just to look around. The Moorish-style brick building was recently purchased for $14.5 million by Kink, a Web-based pornography distributor that outgrew its South of Market dungeon.

The armory, built in 1912, served as a military induction and training center during the two world wars. It’s listed on the National Register of Historic Places but has been empty since 1970. In recent years, plans to build apartments, offices and an Internet switching facility never got off the ground.

At present, kids on skateboards practice their moves on its front steps, and homeless people sleep in its doorways. Its windows are broken and boarded up, its walls covered with graffiti, and its dungeonlike basement is peeling, chipping, rotting and moldering.

Nothing wrong with that, say the pornographers. A real, ready-made dungeon is just the thing for filming bondage movies.

Filming could begin inside the 200,000-square-foot armory as early as next month. To get ready for that happy day, Mogul wandered the crumbling corridors of the enormous dark and dank basement, scouting locations.

“I see tied-up girls, right here,” Mogul said, standing in what was the soldiers’ gymnasium. “You suspend them from these arches. This will be very cool.”

In the boiler room, Mogul said, the possibilities are endless.

“You could put a girl right inside the boiler,” he said. “Why not? It’s a nice little chamber. You wouldn’t have to change anything. It’s already formidable looking. You don’t have to build a fake dungeon; this building is already a dungeon.”

The boiler room and an adjoining room with a giant industrial fan were arousing Mogul’s artistic impulses.

“I see erotic whipping,” he said. “I see all kinds of kinky things going on in here. It’s wonderful to put soft human flesh next to ugly, industrial machines. That’s what we call juxtaposition. The possibilities are endless.”

Mogul, a 41-year-old filmmaker from Boston, said many pornographers went to fancy film schools to learn their craft, but he never found that necessary.

“I got my start tying up my girlfriend,” he said. “It all took off from there.”

Mogul writes, directs and produces an hourlong porn film every week for “Men in Pain,” one of nine Web sites in the Kink chain. At last count, about 70,000 subscribers worldwide were paying $25 a month to gain access to the Web sites, according to founder and owner Peter Acworth, the fellow who bought the armory.

At present, the company’s porn movies are filmed, edited and produced in a two-story building on Mission Street, a block from the San Francisco Centre shopping complex. That building features a dozen sets, including a castle, dungeon, jail, barn, boudoir and what looks like a spaceship. Alas, the Mission Street building has grown too small for the nine movies that must be shot every week.

Acworth said not only is the armory big enough to meet all his porn needs, he also plans to rent out extra space in the building to mainstream filmmakers.

“It could soon become the San Francisco Film Center,” he said.

Residents aren’t quite sure what to make of their new neighbor. Luis Granados, the executive director of the Mission Economic Development Association, said his group found it had no legal grounds to object to having a pornographer next door.

“Whatever you might think about what they’re doing, it’s perfectly legal,” he said. “Do I think it’s a good fit for our family-based neighborhood? No, I don’t.”

Kink will do its part to fit in, said Acworth, pledging to fix the broken windows and the graffiti right away. Kink is proud to bring its high standards to the neighborhood, he added, because Kink stands for decency in pornography. “We have values,” Acworth said. “We believe in showing respect toward women in our work.”

As for vulgarity, Acworth said, that’s all relative. The building’s original purpose, he pointed out, was to train soldiers to kill people.

“That’s obscenity,” he said. “What we plan to do is nothing compared with what this building was intended for.”

Via Sparkle*Matrix

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture, Sexism in the Media | Comments Off on Ex-armory turns into porn site; SF Chron reporter delighted

Pornographers Reluctant To Embrace “High Definition” Format Because It Makes The Female Actors Look Too Human

Revolting NYT story here. The basic thesis is that women will have to work harder at physical perfection (or at least a perfect appearance) if they want to appear in “high definition” pornography because porn consumers don’t want to see their razor burns, cellulite, or blemishes.

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture | Comments Off on Pornographers Reluctant To Embrace “High Definition” Format Because It Makes The Female Actors Look Too Human

More Roe Anniversary Activism

Happy Birthday Roe! Looking for another way to commemorate the day? Donate to your local abortion fund. The Hyde Amendment is 30 years old, which means for 30 years poor women seeking abortions have had to scrape together whatever funds they can out of the money they would otherwise use for housing, food, children’s necessities, etc. . . . while all other procedures are paid for by Medicaid. Do what you can to end this policy and help make the promise of Roe a reality for poor women too.

– David S. Cohen

Share
Posted in Reproductive Rights | Comments Off on More Roe Anniversary Activism

Today is Blog For Choice Day: Try a Little Emergency Contraception Activism!


Blog for Choice Day - January 22, 2007

Learn more here.

Inspired by this post and this post, let me suggest a fairly simple activist act you can try today, or any day: Go to your local pharmacy and ask if it carries Plan B. If the answer is “no,” ask why not.

Share
Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Today is Blog For Choice Day: Try a Little Emergency Contraception Activism!

Need a Reminder About How Many Anti-Feminist “Liberals” There Are?

For the feminist part of the excercise, go read Gloria Steinem’s essay at Alternet entitled   “Why Being a Feminist Does Not Mean Backing All Women.” Then for the backlash, read the appended comments. Yeesh.

–Ann Bartow

Share
Posted in Chutes and Ladders, Feminism and Politics | Comments Off on Need a Reminder About How Many Anti-Feminist “Liberals” There Are?

“The Sound the Stars Make Rushing Through the Sky: The Writings of Jane Johnston Schoolcraft”

schoolcraft.jpg

From the publisher’s website:

Introducing a dramatic new chapter to American Indian literary history, this book brings to the public for the first time the complete writings of the first known American Indian literary writer, Jane Johnston Schoolcraft (her English name) or Bamewawagezhikaquay (her Ojibwe name), Woman of the Sound the Stars Make Rushing Through the Sky (1800-1842). Beginning as early as 1815, Schoolcraft wrote poems and traditional stories while also translating songs and other Ojibwe texts into English. Her stories were published in adapted, unattributed versions by her husband, Henry Rowe Schoolcraft, a founding figure in American anthropology and folklore, and they became a key source for Longfellow’s sensationally popular The Song of Hiawatha.

As this remarkably original volume shows, what little has been known about Schoolcraft’s writing and life only scratches the surface of her legacy. Most of the works have been edited from manuscripts and appear in print here for the first time. The Sound the Stars Make Rushing Through the Sky presents a collection of all Schoolcraft’s known writings along with a cultural and biographical history. Robert Dale Parker’s deeply researched account places her writings in relation to American Indian and American literary history and the history of anthropology, offering the story of Schoolcraft, her world, and her fascinating family as reinterpreted through her newly uncovered writing. This book makes available a startling new episode in the history of American culture and literature.

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture, Recommended Books | Comments Off on “The Sound the Stars Make Rushing Through the Sky: The Writings of Jane Johnston Schoolcraft”

Three Strange and Disturbing Old Movie Trailers

Sellers of Girls

Five Wild Girls

The Pill

All via Bedazzled.

Share
Posted in Bloggenpheffer, Feminism and Culture, Uncategorized | Comments Off on Three Strange and Disturbing Old Movie Trailers

“About Being Considered ‘Retarded'”

One of many very powerful videos by “Silentmiaow.”

Share
Posted in Women's Health | Comments Off on “About Being Considered ‘Retarded'”

And the Number of Female Authors Published In the January 2007 Edition of the Yale Law Journal Appears To Be…

Zero.

Share
Posted in Academia, Feminists in Academia, Law Schools | Comments Off on And the Number of Female Authors Published In the January 2007 Edition of the Yale Law Journal Appears To Be…

Brian Leiter Poses The Query: “How Far Will Law Schools Go to Win the Rankings Race?”

And answers:

Why, as far as it takes, of course, at least as long as manipulation and deceit yield results.

Rankings metrics could value (and therefore incentivize) things like diversity in student bodies, instead of rewarding rich law schools for hiring their own unemployed graduates, but of course they don’t.

Share
Posted in Academia, Law Schools | Comments Off on Brian Leiter Poses The Query: “How Far Will Law Schools Go to Win the Rankings Race?”

Women generally have better credit scores than men, but pay considerably more for mortgages than men

The Consumer Federation of America (CFA) reports:

Women are more likely to receive subprime home mortgage than men and these higher rates of subprime lending make it harder for households headed by women to build wealth through homeownership. In 2005, about a third of women took out mortgages with interest rates over 7.66 percent (well above the average prime mortgage rate of 5.87 percent) compared to about a quarter of men…”

A new CFA study:

…examined 4.4 million mortgage originations throughout the country where borrowers identified their gender. CFA examined borrower incomes based on the Area Median Income where they lived to analyze comparable borrowers across the country. The CFA analysis found that the subprime disparity between women and men increased for women with higher incomes relative to men with similar earnings.

Although women earning below the area median income were 8 percent more likely to receive subprime loans than similarly earning men, women earning more than double the area median income were 50 more likely to receive subprime loans than men with similar earnings.

“Evidence suggests that women have slightly higher credit scores on average than men and similar credit usage patterns, yet the fact that women are more likely to receive more expensive mortgages at all income levels undercuts the lending industries calm assurances that borrowers are priced based on their creditworthiness,”said Allen Fishbein, Director of Housing and Credit Policy at CFA.

African American and Latino women had the highest incidences of subprime lending – and the gap between women of color and white men increased as incomes rose. African American women earning double the area median income were nearly five times more likely to receive subprime home purchase mortgages than white men with similar incomes and Latino women earning twice the area median income were about four times more likely to receive subprime purchase mortgages than white men with similar earnings. African American women make up half the African American purchase mortgage borrowers and Latino women make up nearly a third of Latino home purchase mortgage borrowers. …

Via the NYT.

Share
Posted in Feminism and Law, Sexism in the Media | Comments Off on Women generally have better credit scores than men, but pay considerably more for mortgages than men

CNN and the Feminist-as-Man-Hater Stereotype (Again)

Last week, the Paula Zahn NOW show on CNN ran a segment called “The Duke Assault Case: A Question of Race.”   One of the guests on the show was feminist academic Gail Dines of Wheelock College.   Professor Dines describes the hate-mail she received in response to her television appearance in CNN’s ‘Journalism’ is a Fool’s Paradise”  over at commondreams.org:

When I got back to the hotel 30 minutes later, I already had a few emails from enraged men informing me that I am a”bitch dyke,”“dumb feminist”and”nigger lover”who is an embarrassment to the academic profession. By the next day at noon, it was a flood of emails, each one more hateful than the next . . . .

Rather than being about racism and sexism in the media, the show had been billed as an examination of the”rush to judgment”on the part of the media and society. The possibility that these men were guilty had been”proved”wrong, as the victim is clearly lying and motivated by money.   The case is framed as a”race”issue, which for producers meant that blacks are out for revenge for past misdeeds by whites. Jumping on this bandwagon, so the story goes, was the District Attorney Mike Nifong, who was trying to curry favor with the black community in a re-election year. The consensus on the show was that if anyone is guilty here, it is the lying, immoral black stripper and the amoral, politically motivated DA. The victims here are the upstanding white men who have now had their reputations tarnished first by a stripper and then by gullible fools who believed her. And of course, within the framing of the show, I appeared as not just a gullible fool, but even worse, a gullible fool with a feminist agenda.

My anger at the way the media humanized these men as victims and dehumanized the woman as the perpetrator of a lie clearly stood out from the rest of the show.   And this was, I am now convinced, the producer’s goal.   I was set up in the show to be an example of the problem — white liberal elites who have taken political correctness too far. I was not brought on as a researcher or activist but as an example of how feminists”rush to judgment”in order to further their man-hating propaganda . . . .

Virtually every email I have received blasts me as a conniving feminist who didn’t even bother to know the facts of the case . . . . The truth is that we actually have access to very little evidence about that night, yet every man who has emailed me is convinced that all the facts are out there and only a feminist fool would believe otherwise. This is because the”facts,”or lack of, speak for themselves and tell their own story in a society where racist and sexist ideology is internalized by a good percentage of the population and subsequently writ large onto a black woman’s body. Let’s not forget that this woman was bought and sold in the white male marketplace of sexual entertainment.

The media still delights in caricaturing feminists as angry, irrational man-haters and there seem to be plenty of people who are ready to buy into that stereotype.   But the real haters are the ones sending the nasty emails to Dines.  

A CNN transcript of the program is available here.

– Posted by Bridget Crawford

Share
Posted in Sexism in the Media | Comments Off on CNN and the Feminist-as-Man-Hater Stereotype (Again)

Want to Blog For Hillary?

The Hillary Clinton For President Exploratory Committee is about to launch a new blog, and they’ve decided to let a reader write the first guest post on the blog! The announcement is here and it notes:

Soon we’ll launch the official blog of HillaryClinton.com, a crucial part of our exciting national conversation about the direction of our country and the place to go to learn more about Hillary.

We know our readers are going to have a lot to say, so we want to give you the first word.

We’re looking for your ideas on how we can work together for change. If you’d like to write the very first guest post on the HillaryClinton.com blog, submit your entry in the form below. And if you already have your own blog or other website, please post your entry there and let us know about it. We’ll select one entry as the first guest post on our blog.

Via bobc.

Share
Posted in Bloggenpheffer, Feminism and Politics | Comments Off on Want to Blog For Hillary?

Nancy Rapoport Has a New Blog!

Go here and say hello!

Share
Posted in Feminist Blogs Of Interest, Feminists in Academia | Comments Off on Nancy Rapoport Has a New Blog!

On Jailing Philanderers

A Yahoo News article entitled “Cheat on your spouse in Michigan and spend life in prison?” reports:

Philanderers beware: spouses caught cheating in Michigan could end up spending the rest of their life in prison.

And not the emotional kind.

The state’s appeals court recently ruled that extramarital flings can be prosecuted as first-degree criminal sexual conduct, a felony punishable by up to life in jail.

“We cannot help but question whether the Legislature actually intended the result we reach here today,” Judge William Murphy wrote in a unanimous Court of Appeals panel, “but we are curtailed by the language of the statute from reaching any other conclusion.”

“Technically,” he added, “any time a person engages in sexual penetration in an adulterous relationship, he or she is guilty of CSC I,” the most serious sexual assault charge in the state’s criminal code.

Michigan still lists adultery as a felony, although no one has been convicted of the offense since 1971.

Nobody really expects prosecutors to go after cheating spouses. But the ruling has the local legal community twittering about its genuine intended target.

One theory floating around the courthouse is that the judges were taking a jab at the state Supreme Court, which has decreed that judges must interpret statutory language adopted by the Legislature literally, whatever the consequences.

Many other states allow judges to reject a literal interpretation if they believe it would lead to an absurd result.

Judge Murphy wrote that he encouraged “the Legislature to take a second look at the statutory language if they are troubled by our ruling.”

A spokesman for the attoney general, who publicly admitted to adultery in November, declined to say whether they would press for legislative amendments to make it clear that only violent felonies involving an unwilling victim could trigger a first-degree CSC charge.

“This is so bizarre that it doesn’t even merit a response,” Rusty Hill said.

The appeals court decision involved a man convicted of trading prescription painkillers for sex.

In an attempt to increase his jail time, prosecutors used an obscure provision of the state’s criminal law to charge him with criminal sexual conduct, which occurs whenever “sexual penetration occurs under circumstances involving the commission of any other felony.”

Obviously this is problematic for many reasons. Here is perhaps a less obvious one: People who expect to need alimony or child or spousal support out of a soon-to-be ex-spouse will NOT want the “adulterer” in jail, so they will not want to involve the criminal justice system. The people who will call the police on a cheating spouse and encourage criminal prosecution are those who are willing and able to sacrifice wage-related financial support from the person in the interest of punishing the straying spouse, and gaining full custody of any children. This means that people who earn little or do not work outside the home at all are probably at greatest risk of this kind of prosecution. If the Michigan Court of Apeals is just using this ruling as a mechanism for tweaking the Legislature, I hope the underlying law is changed quickly in reponse, and no one gets hurt.

–Ann Bartow

Update: Mythago has more here.

Share
Posted in Feminism and Law | Comments Off on On Jailing Philanderers

Susan Frelich Appleton, “Gender, Abortion, and Travel After Roe’s End”

Appletons.jpg

Susan Frelich Appleton‘s abtract:

This essay responds to Professor Richard Fallon’s 2006 Childress Lecture at St. Louis University School of Law, If Roe Were Overruled: Abortion and the Constitution in a Post-Roe World. Professor Fallon’s paper exposes as fallacies four popular beliefs about the legal landscape after Roe’s end, including the belief that states restricting abortion will and can reach conduct only within their territorial boundaries. As he persuasively explains, criminal authority probably extends beyond state lines, and the outer limits of a state’s criminal legislative jurisdiction pose a host of contested issues, including the tension between national and state citizenship.

This response makes, and then develops, three principal points. First, it both explains and demonstrates why Professor Fallon’s focus on fetuses and the place of conception misses the fact that, over the years and still today, abortion restrictions aim to police gender roles, not to protect fetuses. Second, it shows what this purpose of regulating gender means – under modern choice-of-law analyses and constitutional doctrine – for Professor Fallon’s hypothesized criminal prohibitions on extraterritorial abortions. Third, it considers recent developments that suggest less controversial but equally effective alternatives for deterring out-of-state abortion activity: civil remedies, principally tort liability, but also injunctive relief.

This essay concludes by challenging Professor Fallon’s self-proclaimed nonnormative position about whether the Supreme Court should overrule Roe. Instead, I express my opposition to overruling Roe, situating this opposition in a long line of important choice-of-law cases and commentary about rules that subordinated women and constrained their agency.

The article can be downloaded here!

Share
Posted in Feminist Legal Scholarship, Reproductive Rights | Comments Off on Susan Frelich Appleton, “Gender, Abortion, and Travel After Roe’s End”

Ellen Goodman, “Roadblock to abortion compromise”

Here is an excerpt from Goodman’s recent column:

It’s not an accident that one of the first bills in the Senate with a new Democratic majority was the Prevention First Act, a wide-ranging family-planning initiative. Rep. Louise Slaughter will follow next week with a similar bill described in one mouthful as a “bipartisan, bicameral, pro-choice, pro-life innovative approach to reducing unintended pregnancies.” Then, Reps. Rosa DeLauro and Tim Ryan, a pro-choice/pro-life duo, will reintroduce an omnibus family-planning and family-support bill with the lumbering title, “The Reducing the Need for Abortions and Supporting Parents Act.”

But there is a roadblock to this common ground. The man overseeing it is Eric Keroack, the brand new head of the Office of Population Affairs. Keroack has, to put it mildly, marched to a different drummer. One heard more often in the March for Life.

As Cecile Richards, head of Planned Parenthood, says, “You have to search far and wide to find a doctor who opposes family planning to run the nation’s family-planning program.” This White House found one. The president picked Keroack just weeks after the election delivered anti-choice defeats. “He didn’t get the memo,” says Nancy Keenan, head of NARAL Pro-Choice America.

Keroack is an OB-GYN who was the medical director for A Woman’s Concern, a network of faith-based “crisis pregnancy centers” in Massachusetts. This group not only promotes abstinence until marriage, it regards birth control as “demeaning to women, degrading of human sexuality and adverse to human health and happiness.”

Read the whole thing here. Also, the text of the Prevention First Act is available here.

Share
Posted in Feminism and Law, Reproductive Rights | Comments Off on Ellen Goodman, “Roadblock to abortion compromise”

CFP:”Space Security”

From the CFP:

Icfai Center for Business Research, ICBR, (Bangalore) India (a part of ICFAI Business School) is set up for raising the standards of knowledge creation and dissemination through research and publication in the area of Business Management. ICFAI Business School (IBS), originally sponsored by ICFAI in 1994, is a constituent of the ICFAI University. ICFAI University is headquartered at Hyderabad, India, with Sixteen Centers spread across the country. ICBR is committed to promote quality education, research, training and consultancy in Management discipline. It caters to the information needs of students, teachers and practitioners of management. Our publications are priced to recover the cost of editing, printing and distribution and not for making profits. Any surplus over and above the costs is included in the publication/academic pool for the above referred objectives only. Further details about our books are available on our website at www.icfaipress.org/books

At present, ICBR is engaged in bringing out a derivative book on “Space Security”. ICBR accepts original submissions on issues in space and space security. The proposed book would broadly focus on three key areas namely military, commercial/economic and environmental issues related to space and use of the space. Prospective papers should be between 3,000 and 10,000 words. All submissions should be addressed to the Consulting Editor, Sukhvinder Kaur Multani at

sukhvinder@ibsindia.org OR sukhvinder_m@yahoo.com.

Ph: 91-080-26393697, Ext-32
Fax-91-080-26493696.
Icfai
Center for Business Research
Icfai
Business School,
J.P.Nagar, 3rd Phase
Bangalore-78
India
.

Important Dates
February 5th, 2007 – Deadline for submission of one page detailed synopsis of the paper.
February 20th, 2007
– Deadline for submission of completed papers.

Share
Posted in Call for Papers or Participation | Comments Off on CFP:”Space Security”

Katie Couric: “A Woman At The Table”

From Couric & Co.:

Last Wednesday, President Bush gave his address to the country about “the new way forward”for Iraq, and lots of journalists:including me, of course:were in Washington to cover it. But before the Big Speech, there was the little-known Big Meeting.

The White House invited all the network anchors, and some cable anchors, along with the Sunday political show hosts to a meeting with unnamed VERY senior administration officials. (Obviously I know their names, but the agreement was that in order to attend the meeting, we couldn’t reveal the people who spoke to us.)

And even though I’ve been in this business for more years than I’d like to admit, and interviewed countless Presidents and world leaders, it’s still thrilling:and even a little awe-inspiring:to get”briefed”at the White House, no matter who is sitting in the Oval Office.

And yet, the meeting was a little disconcerting as well. As I was looking at my colleagues around the room:Charlie Gibson, George Stephanopoulos, Brian Williams, Tim Russert, Bob Schieffer, Wolf Blitzer, and Brit Hume:I couldn’t help but notice, despite how far we’ve come, that I was still the only woman there. Well, there was some female support staff near the door. But of the people at the table, the”principals”in the meeting, I was the only one wearing a skirt. Everyone was gracious, though the jocular atmosphere was palpable.

The feminist movement that began in the 1970’s helped women make tremendous strides:but there still haven’t been enough great leaps for womankind. Fifty-one percent of America is female, but women make up only about sixteen percent of Congress:which, as the Washington Monthly recently pointed out, is better than it’s ever been…but still not as good as parliaments in Rwanda (forty-nine percent women) or Sweden (forty-seven percent women). Only nine Fortune 500 companies have women as CEO’s.

That meeting was a reality check for me:and not just about Iraq. It was a reminder that all of us still have an obligation to ask: Don’t more women deserve a place at the table too?

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture, Sexism in the Media | Comments Off on Katie Couric: “A Woman At The Table”

Hmmm…

britrep.jpg

Welcome to BritishReparations.org, the official site of the International Coalition for British Reparations. We are a global network of citizens who have suffered injuries at the hands of the British Empire over the last five hundred years. We’ve banded together to ask the United Kingdom to compensate the world for all the damage they’ve done.

Think there could be a feminst angle on this?

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture, Sisters In Other Nations | Comments Off on Hmmm…

Why Is It So Difficult To Talk About The Nexus Between Alcohol Consumption, and Sex That Is Uncomfortable, Unwanted, or Worse?

A while back a college student named Liz Funk posted an op-ed at Women’s e-news that drew a lot of criticism because it was rather appallingly framed in a way that made rape victims seem at least partly responsible for the violence that was inflicted upon them.

I’ve discussed related issues with students in a variety of contexts, sometimes because they have asked me to help them deal with the consequences of negative (to put it mildly) social or sexual experiences. I asked several current and former students for their opinions of the Funk piece. One commonly expressed reaction was that Funk had at least correctly observed that bars and clubs hosting free or discounted drink schemes are attractive to predators, including sexual predators, thieves, and people who like to start fights and engage in physical violence against strangers. This was true regardless of whether the drink specials were available to all patrons, or were “female only.” However, they did feel the dynamic at a “Ladies Night” tended to be especially problematic. All the students I consulted had advice they might give a friend or sibling about navigating a club scene safely, but after witnessing the reaction to Funk’s article, none was willing to blog about this here, fearing that they would be accused of “victim blaming and slut shaming.” I don’t know if this concern was justified, nor can I be entirely sure that some portions of their advice couldn’t legitimately be interpreted as victim blaming. But it worries me that they felt silenced.

After hearing so many sad and awful stories, and finding so many “Ladies Night” fliers on my car windshield, it’s hard for me to think about this issue without feeling a desire to warn my students, especially the females, not to drink excessively in unsafe situations; circumstances that start out seeming safe, but then go horribly wrong, without notice or reason. But what useful things can I tell them?

If advertising free or discounted admission or drinks for women only is a mechanism by which both women and men are lured into an establishment, something “gendered” is happening. Moreover, none of my students recalled seeing a bar or club advertise free admission or drink specials pitched exclusively at men. How can we talk about this imbalance productively? Is there a way, without blaming or shaming any victims of sexual assault, to prevent future victims, and to call out the victimizers? In a recent article posted at The American Prospect, Courtney E. Martin has suggested that high quality, comprehensive sex education might have a role to play. You can read her analysis here.

–Ann Bartow

Share
Posted in Acts of Violence, Feminism and Culture, Sociolinguistics | Comments Off on Why Is It So Difficult To Talk About The Nexus Between Alcohol Consumption, and Sex That Is Uncomfortable, Unwanted, or Worse?

A Rape Story

The Miami Herald posted a story about a man accused of raping and torturing his wife to make porn video. Another account, from CNN, is here. It reports:
A man kidnapped his wife, raped and tortured her and then hung her from a tree to film a two-hour bondage porn video, authorities said Tuesday.

The 30-year-old man was charged with aggravated assault and battery, sexual battery, kidnapping and false imprisonment. He was being held in the Brevard County Jail Tuesday on a $3 million bond.

”I don’t know how to even explain it,” said Brevard County sheriff’s Deputy Marlon Buggs. “The attack may not have caused a death or serious injury, but the victim will be mentally scarred.”

The Associated Press does not identify victims of sexual assault. The man was not identified in an effort to safeguard his wife’s identity.

The couple went on a canoe trip down a canal in Brevard County Saturday and pulled ashore near some trees. The man began raping the woman and then got a video camera to tape the act, Buggs said.

He tied her to a nearby tree, where she hung naked for several hours, her toes grazing the ground, Buggs said. …

Corey Rayburn Yung, at the Sex Crimes blog, observed:

An interesting part of this case is that it presents the rare case of a sensational rape story committed by someone known to the victim. As scholars, especially feminist ones, have emphasized for decades, most rapes are not committed by strangers. Yet, media, cultural, and legal attention is often focused on the stranger “lurking in the bushes.” Normally, the rape committed by a person known to the victim lacks the lurid details to garner significant media coverage. This case is the exception that helps prove the rule. It is one of the few rape cases committed by a person with a substantial social connection to the victim that is subject to national media attention.

Share
Posted in Acts of Violence, Feminism and Law | Comments Off on A Rape Story

Thirtieth Carnival of the Feminists

Here, at Girlistic.com.

Share
Posted in Carnival time!, Feminist Blogs Of Interest, Uncategorized | Comments Off on Thirtieth Carnival of the Feminists

The ERA Campaign Network

The ERA Campaign Newtork is “[a] network of people all around the United States, supporting and/or working to achieve the addition of The Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) to our United States Constitution.” Check out their informative website. Also, there is a similar site here for another ERA advocacy organization, 4ERA.org.

Share
Posted in Feminism and Politics | Comments Off on The ERA Campaign Network

Meredith Render, “The Man, the State and You: The Role of the State in Regulating Gender Hierarchies”

The abstract:

This paper begins with the thesis that an andocentric-assimilation model of women’s liberation both has affected workplace outcomes for women and has desensitized us to those outcomes. The paper then applies that thesis to understandings of “equality” within a hierarchical framework, arguing that the equality-liberty dichotomy is false in the context of gender discrimination in the workplace. Instead the paper argues that disparate treatment is a liberty concern. In seeking to have our professional fates married to the fates of our male colleagues – which is what workplace equality doctrines aim to do – women are seeking to be only as free as our male colleagues are to find work and to find meaning in our work, to procreate or not, to coast along or to stand out, and, if we choose, to stand alone. Further, this paper offers the perspective that as feminist advocates we should resist the inclination to make our peace with the ordering of the gendered paradigms as they stand and to negotiate compromises from these vantage points. Within this theoretical framework, this paper explores the implications of the “regulation” versus “governance” debate in the context of gender discrimination. The article suggests that renaming and reframing aside, the approach embodied by the governance paradigm as it is applied to gender discriminatory contexts is neither new nor a deal for those already occupying a subordinate bargaining position, but it is instead a framework by which to privilege existing power structures and efficiency-based values over other values and interests. Moreover, this paper defends the civil rights model of rules-base state-enforced mandatory anti-discrimination measures, such as Title VII, as an admittedly non-panacean yet nonetheless indispensable means by which private gender hierarchies are inhibited. Finally, this paper contends that in looking to the law to inhibit this particular privately-enforced tyranny, women are correctly interpreting the obligation of the state within our constitutional scheme to disrupt private tyrannies when those tyrannies reach the point of functioning as class-based power monopolies, limiting the fundamental freedoms of those outside the monopolist class.

Downloadable in full text here.

Share
Posted in Feminism and Law, Feminist Legal Scholarship | Comments Off on Meredith Render, “The Man, the State and You: The Role of the State in Regulating Gender Hierarchies”

Johanna’s Law

The President signed Johanna’s Law on Friday, providing for a gynecological awareness and education campaign. Since many gynecological cancers are not diagnosed until they are in the later stages, they can be particularly deadly. I am copying our press release in the hopes that you may find the information useful or interesting. Please contact me if you have any questions or concerns.

Cara Tenenbaum
Policy Director

President Bush Signs ‘Johanna’s Law’ to Launch a National Gynecologic Awareness Campaign

President Bush has signed Johanna’s Law, landmark legislation that authorizes development of a national gynecologic cancer awareness campaign. The federal campaign would educate American women and health professionals about the signs and symptoms of ovarian and other gynecologic cancers.

The President signed the bill on Friday, January 12. Both houses of Congress unanimously approved Johanna’s Law: the Gynecologic Cancer Education and Awareness Act late last year.

Johanna’s Law authorizes $16.5 million over a three-year period to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services for the awareness and education campaign. It is named for Johanna Silver Gordon, who died from ovarian cancer in 2000.

“This achievement is the result of the tireless work and dedication of all of our Congressional champions, the Society of Gynecologic Oncologists, and a far-reaching alliance of grassroots activists whose lives have been touched by gynecologic cancers,”said Sherry Salway Black , executive director of the Ovarian Cancer National Alliance.”The ovarian cancer community in particular has played a critical role in the passage of Johanna’s Law through the Ovarian Cancer Action Network.”

“This is an exciting development in our efforts to save women’s lives through earlier detection of ovarian cancer,”said Johanna’s sister, Sheryl Silver, who conceived Johanna’s Law and has worked tirelessly for its passage.”By educating the public about the risk factors and symptoms of gynecologic cancers, Johanna’s Law will help women recognize potentially dangerous symptoms and seek appropriate medical attention sooner.”

OCAN and other advocates now have another hurdle to overcome. Because Johanna’s Law is an authorizing measure, it does not include any appropriations, so OCAN and other advocates will need to work to urge Congressional funding for the campaign.

Share
Posted in Women's Health | Comments Off on Johanna’s Law

Tillie Olsen Memorial

Via the wonderful Sinister Girl:

Tillie Olsen‘s family would like to let people in the San Francisco Bay Area know about her memorial celebration.

Please circulate this information widely — the family is trying to get this information out to all those who might be interested.
_____

Tillie Lerner Olsen
Author, Feminist, Activist
January 14, 1912 – January 1, 2007

Join family, friends, and readers for a Memorial Celebration of Tillie Olsen’s Life

Saturday, February 17, 2007
First Congregational Church of Oakland
2501 Harrison Street (corner of 25th and Harrison)
Oakland, CA

1:00 celebration followed by reception.

Parking on site. The church is 8 blocks from the 19th Street BART Station.

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture, Upcoming Lectures | Comments Off on Tillie Olsen Memorial

The Sewall-Belmont House and Museum in Washington, DC

From the Museum’s webpage:  

The Sewall-Belmont House and Museum, on Capitol Hill, explores the evolving role of women and their contributions to society through the continuing, and often untold, story of women’s pursuit for equality.

The Museum is the headquarters of the historic National Woman’s Party and was the Washington home of its founder and Equal Rights Amendment author Alice Paul.

Sewall-Belmont, named in the first Save America’s Treasures legislation, is the only museum in the nation’s capitol dedicated to preserving and showcasing a crucial piece of our history:the fight for the American woman’s right to vote. This struggle is documented through one of the most significant collections in the country focused on the suffrage and equal rights movements. …

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture, Feminist Legal History | Comments Off on The Sewall-Belmont House and Museum in Washington, DC

“Jane Fonda on the Fight for An Equitable Media”

From the WMC press release:

In a powerful address to the just concluded National Conference on Media Reform, WMC founding board member Jane Fonda called for a strong and progressive media, one that captures the essence of democracy by fully reporting women’s issues and employing women at all levels of news organizations.   Fonda said an overwhelmingly white and male corps of journalism professionals cannot accurately reflect our world and pointed out the anemic coverage of the story of Abeer Qassim Hamza al-Janabi, the 14-year-old Iraqi girl who was raped and murdered, allegedly by U.S. soldiers. The soldiers are also charged with killing the teenager’s family (the atrocities are the subject of an ongoing WMC campaign). And she told the Memphis gathering organized by the Free Press”When we talk about reforming the media, what we’re really talking about is creating a media that is powerful, not a media that serves the interests of the powerful…”   The commentary on these critical issues…today at www.womensmediacenter.com

Share
Posted in Sexism in the Media | Comments Off on “Jane Fonda on the Fight for An Equitable Media”

Internet Shaming

The WSJ reported:

Last month, Eva Burgess was eating breakfast at the Rose Cafe in Venice, Calif., when she remembered she needed to make an appointment with her eye doctor. So the New York theater director got on her cellphone and booked a date.

Almost immediately, she started receiving “weird and creepy” calls directing her to a blog. There, under the posting “Eva Burgess Is Getting Glasses!” her name, cellphone number and other details mentioned in her call to the doctor’s office were posted, along with the admonition, “next time, you might take your business outside.” The offended blogger had been sitting next to Ms. Burgess in the cafe.

It used to be the worst you could get for a petty wrong in public was a rude look. Now, it’s not just brutal police officers, panty-free celebrities and wayward politicians who are being outed online. The most trivial missteps by ordinary folks are increasingly ripe for exposure as well. There is a proliferation of new sites dedicated to condemning offenses ranging from bad parking (Caughtya.org) and leering (HollaBackNYC.com) to littering (LitterButt.com) and general bad behavior (RudePeople.com). One site documents locations where people have failed to pick up after their dogs. Capturing newspaper-stealing neighbors on video is also an emerging genre

At Concurring Opinions, Kaimipono Wenger added:

Quick google-checking turns up the blog in question, AdviceGoddess.com, the site of a syndicated advice columnist named Amy Alkon. Ms. Alkon’s original post does indeed contain Ms. Burgess’s information. In comments to that post, she defends her decision to put that information online, noting that her ire stems in part from Ms. Burgess’s failure to apply the “do unto others” principle. (There is no indication in the comment that Ms. Alkon realizes the irony of that statement.) Later, Ms. Alkon elaborates further:

I posted freely dispensed news. I didn’t wiretap the girl’s phone or listen at her keyhole. She shouted the information out to the public, which suggests that she was happy to have the public in possession of her phone number and all the rest of the information she dispensed.

This “waiver” argument comes up releatedly in comments, as Ms. Alkon and several of her comment interlocutors assert that Ms. Burgess’s public phone conversation destroys any legal expectation of privacy. (See, e.g., comments in this follow-up post at Ms. Alkon’s blog.) In fact, as many readers of this blog probably know, the law is much more complex. In particular, some jurisdictions (including California) have recognized a doctrine of limited privacy.

A very good discussion of the limited privacy doctrine can be found in the recent privacy article by Lior Strahilevitz (who, incidentally, gets mentioned in the WSJ piece for his “How am I driving?” article)   …

Read Wenger’s excellent post in full here.

Share
Posted in Academia, Feminism and Culture, Legal Profession | Comments Off on Internet Shaming

The Cringe Book

Here’s the Cringe book webpage, which says:

We’re looking for brave souls willing to share their old diaries, journals, letters, notes, songs, poems… anything you wrote during the crushing misery of adolescence and then saved in a hidden box at your parents’ house all these years. Top secret no more.

The more dramatic, embarrassing or excruciating the writing, the better. A good test to determine whether or not your material is Cringe-worthy: when you read it to yourself, do you physically cringe? Then for the love of god, it needs to be in this book. Seriously. You are going to be so glad you did this. Cheaper and better than therapy.

Via Dooce, who posted a page from her old journal.

Share
Posted in Sociolinguistics | Comments Off on The Cringe Book

Interview with Martha Nussbaum in Eurozine

Available here. Below is an excerpt:

SV: And one final question about feminism, a more philosophical question. I have always felt that you have a critical attitude towards the more extreme feminist views. I think of people like Andrea Dworkin and to some extent Catharine MacKinnon. To what extent has your intervention influenced this sort of more radical feminist? Have things changed do you think, have things become more balanced today?

MN: My view about MacKinnon and Dworkin is extremely positive, as I’ve said both in Sex and Social Justice and in Hiding From Humanity. I think that both are great and I have great enthusiasm for their views. I don’t agree with absolutely everything.

SV: You tend to be more universal, more ecumenical…

MN: MacKinnon thinks that she is an opponent of liberalism. And she thinks that, because when she went to graduate school liberalism was very underdeveloped and wasn’t thinking about women’s issues at all. Especially in law, liberalism was just talking about how all principles should be neutral, and so she thought that it makes no room for affirmative action. For example, there were insurance companies that did not give pregnancy benefits and legal liberals argued that this was OK, there is no sex discrimination here, because all non-pregnant persons, both male and female, are going to get the benefits. And she thought that this was ridiculous and of course it was. But that sort of obtuseness is not entailed by liberalism. She had never studied Rawls, she had never studied Dworkin, she had never studied any of the really theoretical works that think that there’s a Kantian idea of human equality and human dignity at the bottom of liberalism. She’s stressed that she had studied Mill, and she thought Mill was great, you know she is my colleague so I talk to her all the time. So she really objected to a kind of neutralism that was very influential in the legal realm, that made affirmative action for women impossible and refused to take seriously these differences of power. But of course Rawls never had that failing.

My primary difference with MacKinnon is that she is reluctant to express any universal norms or ideals. I think the reason for this is her Marxist background, because she thinks we first have to have the revolution and then once the revolution has taken place, women themselves will say what they want to say. She thinks it’s too dictatorial to announce ahead of time what the norms are. However, in her writings there’s a very obvious normative structure. There are ideas of dignity and equality. Andrea Dworkin is actually explicit about this, and in fact MacKinnon will say “Oh yes, that’s the humanism in Andrea that I always find so unfortunate.” She herself will admit that Andrea is sort of on my side in this debate. But I think she herself is, when you philosophically reconstruct her views. I don’t think you can do it without employing normative notions; to the extent that she does avoid them it just means that her own ideas are underdeveloped and that there’s not enough of a principled structure. I think that her views about sexual harassment are very, very important. Her emphasis on differences of power in the workplace is extremely important, as is her idea that what we have to look at is not just sameness or difference of treatment but the underlying structures of power. I think it’s a liberal idea. I differ with some of her specific claims about pornography. But I don’t actually think that’s so central.

SV: What do you think of Andrea Dworkin’s book Intercourse?

MN: Oh, I think Intercourse is a great book, I teach it all the time, but it’s not about pornography. Andrea Dworkin is a fiction writer really. She’s not a philosopher, so she doesn’t always write with a great deal of definitional precision. I wrote a piece which is in “Sex and Social Justice” about philosophers and prophets in which I contrasted myself with her with some kind of unease, because I think philosophers don’t want to move to the next step until they patiently make the right distinctions. Whereas I think Dworkin is a prophet. Her mentor was Frederick Douglass, she wants to get out there and denounce an evil. And like Frederick Douglass, the great abolitionist, she doesn’t always define her terms precisely. So what I think she really is doing in Intercourse is saying that it’s not just this or that evil offender that we need to be worried about, it is social norms themselves. When men use force against women, it’s not enough to say: oh well that was a bad guy, or: that was a pervert, but that the problem is intrinsic to some of our social norms. Men think they have a right to use force in certain circumstances, when they’ve paid for the woman and they’ve got drunk and so on. Actually sociological evidence shows this. Edward Laumann, who is the greatest sociologist of American sexual behaviour, in his large tome called The Social Organization of Sexuality, said that the biggest problem that emerged from his careful survey of American sexual behaviour was a tremendous discrepancy between men’s perception of what is force in the sexual situation and women’s. Men simply don’t believe that they’re using force if the woman is drunk and they just go right ahead. And then the woman does think that that was force. So I think we made progress in having a social dialogue about that. But when Andrea Dworkin wrote, we hadn’t had that dialogue yet. Still in some states in America, we haven’t had it. Here is one case that was decided in Illinois quite recently. A woman who weighed 95 pounds was riding her bicycle in a forest preserve. A man who weighed 200 pounds came up to her and said: “Will you come with me into the forest? My girlfriend doesn’t satisfy my needs”. There is no one around, and he just picks her up off the bicycle and without struggling or fighting she goes along with his sexual demands in the woods. He was first convicted of rape, but the high court threw out the conviction saying she hadn’t struggled to the utmost. You see, she was alone; she probably would have died if she had struggled! That’s the kind of thing Andrea Dworkin is talking about. And the best criminal lawyers are very inspired by her and try to rewrite rape law and try to make it more adequate.

I think MacKinnon and Dworkin have made great contributions. MacKinnon happens to be a very good friend of mine by now also, but she is a great thinker I believe. I think MacKinnon is misunderstood as being a man-hater and that seems to me quite wrong. It’s not as if she hasn’t got some of the blame to bear for that because her writings are not systematic works. They’re public speeches that she delivered in the heat of the moment that were recorded and then published. If my only works were my recorded interviews I would probably be misunderstood. But she should have written a more patient philosophical book. A Feminist Theory of the State is not really that book, because it was her dissertation. It does not answer the questions that philosophers raise about her views. Her new book on international law and women’s human rights is in some ways her best, because its conceptual clarity is very evident.

Again, the full interview can be read here.

–Ann Bartow

Share
Posted in Feminism and Law, Feminists in Academia | Comments Off on Interview with Martha Nussbaum in Eurozine

“Vancouver’s 69 Missing Women: Murdered by Men, Remembered by Women”

Read Heart’s post here. It features portaits…:

…created by a group of artists troubled over the fact that photos of the missing women which appeared in newspapers were stark, dehumanizing mugshots, the women characterized as”prostitutes”or”hookers”   or”drug addicts,”as though any of this were any issue when a woman is murdered.

Share
Posted in Acts of Violence, Feminism and Culture | Comments Off on “Vancouver’s 69 Missing Women: Murdered by Men, Remembered by Women”

Celia R. Daileader, “Racism, Misogyny, and the Othello Myth”

othello.jpg
From the publisher’s webpage:

Through readings of texts spanning four centuries, and bridging the Atlantic – from genres as diverse as English Renaissance drama, abolitionist literature, gothic horror and contemporary romance – Daileader questions why Anglo-American culture’s most widely-read and canonical narratives of inter-racial sex feature a black male and a white female and not a black female and a white male. This study considers the cultural obsession with stories patterned on Shakespeare’s Othello alongside the more historically pertinent, if troubling, question of white male sexual predation upon black females. Daileader terms this phenomenon ‘Othellophilia’ – the fixation on Shakespeare’s tragedy of inter-racial marriage to the exclusion of other definitions and more optimistic visions of inter-racial tension. This original study argues that masculinist racist hegemony used myths about black male sexual rapacity and the danger of racial ‘pollution’ in order to police white female sexuality and exorcise collective guilt over the sexual slavery of women of color.

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture, Feminists in Academia, Recommended Books | Comments Off on Celia R. Daileader, “Racism, Misogyny, and the Othello Myth”

Huck Finn

hflogo.jpg

Go to playwright Nancy McClernan’s blog and read about her new play! Here’s an excerpt from one recent post:

I’ve been reimagining Twain’s Tom/Huck stories since I was a little kid and my friend Laura and I wrote our own version of The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, inserting two new characters – a sister for Tom, modeled on Laura and a sister for Huck, modeled on me. Both girl characters hated Becky Thatcher with a passion, since she represented everything Laura and I hated about how a good girl was supposed to behave. It’s interesting that Twain created the good girl character we despised in the same book as Tom Sawyer, whom Twain saw as an antidote to the idealized good boy character that he despised.

Nancy is very funny and smart, and I wish I lived in NYC so I could see this play. More info here.

–Ann Bartow

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture, Feminist Blogs Of Interest | Comments Off on Huck Finn

Today, In Honor of Dr. King, Remember That The First “C” In SCLC Stands For Christian

homepage_logo_bottom_2007.gif

The American Civil Rights Movement was born and nurtured in the African American churches of the South, and the first President of the SCLC was Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Today, try to remember that while a whole lot of awful things have been done in the name of Christianity, and many bad people call themselves Christians, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. and Coretta Scott King were Christians too.

No, I am not a Christian, and yes, reports like this makes me very nervous. But there are a large number of African Americans residing in the American South, and a very high percentage of the African Americans who live here define themselves as Christians. Many, I would even say most, are smart, kind-hearted, engaged political progressives. They honor Dr. King with their good works every day.

Expressing bigotry toward Christians, and toward Southerners generally, hurts some very good people, and has racist aspects and overtones as well. So in honor of Dr. King, and because it’s the right thing to do, please knock it off!

Thanks for reading. Sermon over.

–Ann Bartow

Share
Posted in Feminism and Politics, Sociolinguistics | Comments Off on Today, In Honor of Dr. King, Remember That The First “C” In SCLC Stands For Christian

Accidentally Appearing In A Porn Movie Is So Hilarious

At least according to the NYT. And looking for the film he appeared in gives the author a reason to view lots of porn, accordind to the final sentences of the piece, because otherwise he didn’t have one. Or something.

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture, Sexism in the Media | Comments Off on Accidentally Appearing In A Porn Movie Is So Hilarious

Woman in water drinking contest dies

The bottled water sellers lie: People with unfettered access to fluids suffer more frequently from overhydration (a.k.a. water intoxication) than from dehydration. See also. This woman apparently drank herself to death, trying to win a prize for her children.

Update: a NYT blog reports this story here.

Share
Posted in Feminism and Culture, Women's Health | Comments Off on Woman in water drinking contest dies

The Legality of Wiki Linking In Dispute

On 12.21.06 the NYT reported:

For at least a year, Eli Lilly provided information to doctors about the blood-sugar risks of its drug Zyprexa that did not match data that the company circulated internally when it first reviewed its clinical trial results, according to company documents.

The original results showed that patients on Zyprexa, Lilly’s pill for schizophrenia, were 3.5 times as likely to experience high blood sugar levels as those taking a placebo, according to a February 2000 memo sent to top Lilly scientists. The memo is one of hundreds of internal Lilly documents provided to The New York Times by a lawyer in Alaska who represents mentally ill patients.

But the results that Lilly eventually provided to doctors until at least late 2001 were very different. Those results indicated that patients taking Zyprexa were only slightly more likely to suffer high blood sugar as those taking a placebo, or an inactive pill.

Another Lilly report, from November 1999, shows that Lilly found after examining 70 clinical trials that 16 percent of patients taking Zyprexa for a year gained more than 66 pounds.

The New York Times article was apparently based on documents which were leaked from an ongoing Zyprexa products liability lawsuit. Copies of the leaked Eli Lilly documents appeared (or were linked to) on a variety of websites such as this one. Links to the documents were also posted on a wiki at http://zyprexa.pbwiki.com. On January 4, 2007 Judge Jack Weinstein of the E.D.N.Y. enjoined use of the wiki to further disseminate these documents. The estimable Fred von Lohmann of EFF is representing the wiki poster. Read more at the associated EFF webpage.

–Ann Bartow

Update: The NYT has a new article up about this issue here.

Share
Posted in Feminism and Law, Women's Health | Comments Off on The Legality of Wiki Linking In Dispute